Viewers Cautioned on Televised Medical Talk Show Recommendations
By HospiMedica International staff writers Posted on 05 Jan 2015 |
![Image: Study authors Mike Kolber, Christina Korownyck, and Mike Allan (Photo courtesy of the University of Alberta). Image: Study authors Mike Kolber, Christina Korownyck, and Mike Allan (Photo courtesy of the University of Alberta).](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2015-01-05/DJB-621.jpg)
Image: Study authors Mike Kolber, Christina Korownyck, and Mike Allan (Photo courtesy of the University of Alberta).
A new study warns that the public should be skeptical of recommendations made on mainstream television medical talk shows, as they often lack adequate evidence or are contradicted by the best available evidence.
Researchers at the University of Alberta (Edmonton, Canada) chose two internationally syndicated medical talk shows to analyze: The Dr. Oz Show and The Doctors. Each show was recorded every day from January 2013 to April 2013. The researchers then randomly selected 40 episodes of each show and had two team members watch every episode independently, recording topics, recommendations made, and who was making the recommendations. Two other researchers also watched the episodes and review the recommendations, focusing on benefits mentioned, if the magnitude of the benefit was quantified, costs, and conflict of interest.
The researchers found evidence to support 54% of the 160 randomly selected recommendations (80 from each show). For The Dr. Oz Show, evidence supported 46%, contradicted 15%, and was not found for 39%. For The Doctors, evidence supported 63%, contradicted 14%, and was not found for 24%. Believable or somewhat believable evidence supported 33% of the recommendations on The Dr. Oz Show and 53% on The Doctors. The most common recommendation category on The Dr. Oz Show was dietary advice (39%) and on The Doctors was to consult a healthcare provider (18%).
Further findings included a specific benefit for 43% and 41% of the recommendations made on the shows respectively. The magnitude of benefit was described for 17% of the recommendations on The Dr. Oz Show and 11% on The Doctors. Disclosure of potential conflicts of interest accompanied only 0.4% of recommendations for both shows. The study was published in the Christmas edition of the British Medical Journal (BMJ), which was dedicated to media studies.
“Some patients come in and say 'I heard on Dr. Oz yesterday that we should all be doing this.' And then we're left scrambling in our office to try to find answers. It got us reflecting, what's being said there? What kinds of things are being recommended and what kind of information is being provided?” said lead author Christina Korownyk, MD, an associate professor in the department of family medicine. “Frequently you're not getting enough information and without doing the research you won't know if it's supported by evidence or not; the research supporting any of these recommendations is frequently absent, contradictory, or of poor quality.”
Related Links:
University of Alberta
Researchers at the University of Alberta (Edmonton, Canada) chose two internationally syndicated medical talk shows to analyze: The Dr. Oz Show and The Doctors. Each show was recorded every day from January 2013 to April 2013. The researchers then randomly selected 40 episodes of each show and had two team members watch every episode independently, recording topics, recommendations made, and who was making the recommendations. Two other researchers also watched the episodes and review the recommendations, focusing on benefits mentioned, if the magnitude of the benefit was quantified, costs, and conflict of interest.
The researchers found evidence to support 54% of the 160 randomly selected recommendations (80 from each show). For The Dr. Oz Show, evidence supported 46%, contradicted 15%, and was not found for 39%. For The Doctors, evidence supported 63%, contradicted 14%, and was not found for 24%. Believable or somewhat believable evidence supported 33% of the recommendations on The Dr. Oz Show and 53% on The Doctors. The most common recommendation category on The Dr. Oz Show was dietary advice (39%) and on The Doctors was to consult a healthcare provider (18%).
Further findings included a specific benefit for 43% and 41% of the recommendations made on the shows respectively. The magnitude of benefit was described for 17% of the recommendations on The Dr. Oz Show and 11% on The Doctors. Disclosure of potential conflicts of interest accompanied only 0.4% of recommendations for both shows. The study was published in the Christmas edition of the British Medical Journal (BMJ), which was dedicated to media studies.
“Some patients come in and say 'I heard on Dr. Oz yesterday that we should all be doing this.' And then we're left scrambling in our office to try to find answers. It got us reflecting, what's being said there? What kinds of things are being recommended and what kind of information is being provided?” said lead author Christina Korownyk, MD, an associate professor in the department of family medicine. “Frequently you're not getting enough information and without doing the research you won't know if it's supported by evidence or not; the research supporting any of these recommendations is frequently absent, contradictory, or of poor quality.”
Related Links:
University of Alberta
Latest Health IT News
- Machine Learning Model Improves Mortality Risk Prediction for Cardiac Surgery Patients
- Strategic Collaboration to Develop and Integrate Generative AI into Healthcare
- AI-Enabled Operating Rooms Solution Helps Hospitals Maximize Utilization and Unlock Capacity
- AI Predicts Pancreatic Cancer Three Years before Diagnosis from Patients’ Medical Records
- First Fully Autonomous Generative AI Personalized Medical Authorizations System Reduces Care Delay
- Electronic Health Records May Be Key to Improving Patient Care, Study Finds
- AI Trained for Specific Vocal Biomarkers Could Accurately Predict Coronary Artery Disease
- First-Ever AI Test for Early Diagnosis of Alzheimer’s to Be Expanded to Diagnosis of Parkinson’s Disease
- New Self-Learning AI-Based Algorithm Reads Electrocardiograms to Spot Unseen Signs of Heart Failure
- Autonomous Robot Performs COVID-19 Nasal Swab Tests
- Statistical Tool Predicts COVID-19 Peaks Worldwide
- Wireless-Controlled Soft Neural Implant Stimulates Brain Cells
- Tiny Polymer Stent Could Treat Pediatric Urethral Strictures
- Human Torso Simulator Helps Design Brace Innovations
- 3D Bioprinting Rebuilds the Human Heart
Channels
Critical Care
view channel![Image: Researchers have made significant advances in ingestible microbiome sampling pill technology (Photo courtesy of Tufts University) Image: Researchers have made significant advances in ingestible microbiome sampling pill technology (Photo courtesy of Tufts University)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-14/news-2406-ingestible-pill.jpg)
Ingestible Microbiome Sampling Pill to Help Diagnose Wide Range of Health Conditions
The healthy human gut is home to more than 1,000 species of bacteria, most of which play a beneficial role in digestion and protecting against disease. When the natural balance of these microbes is disrupted,... Read more![Image: Association between long-term sudden cardiac death and heart rate variability, measured in different stages of exercise testing (Photo courtesy of Hernesniemi JA, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol EP. 2024;10.1016/j.jacep.2024.04.018) Image: Association between long-term sudden cardiac death and heart rate variability, measured in different stages of exercise testing (Photo courtesy of Hernesniemi JA, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol EP. 2024;10.1016/j.jacep.2024.04.018)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-14/1-s2.0-S2405500X24002962-ga1.jpg)
Breakthrough Computational Method Predicts Sudden Cardiac Death
Unfortunately, sudden cardiac death is often the first indication of heart disease, and it can strike even young, seemingly healthy individuals, particularly during intense physical activity.... Read more![Image: An ingestible smart sensor could detect cancers (Photo courtesy of The Khan lab) Image: An ingestible smart sensor could detect cancers (Photo courtesy of The Khan lab)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-13/Untitled-design-4 (1).jpg)
GPS-Like Smart Pills with AI Provide Real-Time 3D Monitoring Of Gastrointestinal Health
Gas produced in the intestines when bacteria digest food can provide valuable information about a person's health. Currently, to measure gastrointestinal (GI) tract gases, physicians use methods such as... Read moreSurgical Techniques
view channel![Image: New studies suggest benefit of total robotic metabolic and bariatric surgery over conventional laparoscopy (Photo courtesy of 123RF) Image: New studies suggest benefit of total robotic metabolic and bariatric surgery over conventional laparoscopy (Photo courtesy of 123RF)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-13/143615440_m_normal_none.jpg)
Total Robotic Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery Proves More Beneficial than Conventional Laparoscopy
According to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 42.4% of Americans are affected by obesity. Research indicates that obesity can compromise the immune system, trigger chronic inflammation,... Read more![Image: Concept of the wirelessly actuated undulating pump and its integration into an esophageal stent (Photo courtesy of Advanced Functional Materials/ doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202405865) Image: Concept of the wirelessly actuated undulating pump and its integration into an esophageal stent (Photo courtesy of Advanced Functional Materials/ doi.org/10.1002/adfm.202405865)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-11/adfm202405865-fig-0001-m.jpg)
Wirelessly Activated Robotic Device Aids Digestion in Patients with Compromised Organs
The transport of fluids and solids is essential in the human body, driven by a wave-like movement in the lumen known as peristalsis. However, peristalsis can be disrupted in patients who have obstructions... Read morePatient Care
view channel![Image: The portable, handheld BeamClean technology inactivates pathogens on commonly touched surfaces in seconds (Photo courtesy of Freestyle Partners) Image: The portable, handheld BeamClean technology inactivates pathogens on commonly touched surfaces in seconds (Photo courtesy of Freestyle Partners)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-05-01/Freestyle_1.jpg)
First-Of-Its-Kind Portable Germicidal Light Technology Disinfects High-Touch Clinical Surfaces in Seconds
Reducing healthcare-acquired infections (HAIs) remains a pressing issue within global healthcare systems. In the United States alone, 1.7 million patients contract HAIs annually, leading to approximately... Read more![Image: The newly-launched solution can transform operating room scheduling and boost utilization rates (Photo courtesy of Fujitsu) Image: The newly-launched solution can transform operating room scheduling and boost utilization rates (Photo courtesy of Fujitsu)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2023-09-26/SDD-294798729.jpg)
Surgical Capacity Optimization Solution Helps Hospitals Boost OR Utilization
An innovative solution has the capability to transform surgical capacity utilization by targeting the root cause of surgical block time inefficiencies. Fujitsu Limited’s (Tokyo, Japan) Surgical Capacity... Read more![Image: The Instrument Pod is clinically proven to make the OR and sterile processing more efficient (Photo courtesy of Turbett Surgical) Image: The Instrument Pod is clinically proven to make the OR and sterile processing more efficient (Photo courtesy of Turbett Surgical)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2023-07-13/SDD-294797885.jpg)
Game-Changing Innovation in Surgical Instrument Sterilization Significantly Improves OR Throughput
A groundbreaking innovation enables hospitals to significantly improve instrument processing time and throughput in operating rooms (ORs) and sterile processing departments. Turbett Surgical, Inc.... Read morePoint of Care
view channel![Image: POCT offers cost-effective, accessible, and immediate diagnostic solutions (Photo courtesy of Flinders University) Image: POCT offers cost-effective, accessible, and immediate diagnostic solutions (Photo courtesy of Flinders University)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-05-30/28897_about_up_woman_operating_poct_machine.jpg)
POCT for Infectious Diseases Delivers Laboratory Equivalent Pathology Results
On-site pathology tests for infectious diseases in rural and remote locations can achieve the same level of reliability and accuracy as those conducted in hospital laboratories, a recent study suggests.... Read more![Image: The cartridge-based TEG 6s system provides clinicians a complete picture about a patient\'s coagulation profile (Photo courtesy of Haemonetics Corporation) Image: The cartridge-based TEG 6s system provides clinicians a complete picture about a patient\'s coagulation profile (Photo courtesy of Haemonetics Corporation)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-05-28/TEG6s-5-Hospital-Single-Product-Image-429x429-Recovered.jpg)
Cartridge-Based Hemostasis Analyzer System Enables Faster Coagulation Testing
Quickly assessing a patient's total hemostasis status can be critical to influencing clinical outcomes and using blood products. Haemonetics Corporation (Boston, MA, USA) has now obtained 510(k) clearance... Read more![Image: The Quantra Hemostasis System has received US FDA special 510(k) clearance for use with its Quantra QStat Cartridge (Photo courtesy of HemoSonics) Image: The Quantra Hemostasis System has received US FDA special 510(k) clearance for use with its Quantra QStat Cartridge (Photo courtesy of HemoSonics)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-04-05/Quantra_Instrument_QStat_Dials_2022.jpg)
Critical Bleeding Management System to Help Hospitals Further Standardize Viscoelastic Testing
Surgical procedures are often accompanied by significant blood loss and the subsequent high likelihood of the need for allogeneic blood transfusions. These transfusions, while critical, are linked to various... Read moreBusiness
view channel![Image: The Critical Care acquisition will enhance BD’s portfolio of smart connected care solutions (Photo courtesy of BD) Image: The Critical Care acquisition will enhance BD’s portfolio of smart connected care solutions (Photo courtesy of BD)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-06-04/Hemodynamic_Monitoring_1.jpg)
BD Acquires Edwards Lifesciences' Critical Care Product Group for USD 4.2 Billion
BD (Becton, Dickinson and Company, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA) and Edwards Lifesciences (Irvine, CA, USA) have entered into a definitive agreement under which BD will acquire Edwards' Critical Care product... Read more![Image: The MEDICA START-UP PARK is the meeting place for networking for and with the creative start-up scene (Photo courtesy of Constanze Tillmann/Messe Düsseldorf) Image: The MEDICA START-UP PARK is the meeting place for networking for and with the creative start-up scene (Photo courtesy of Constanze Tillmann/Messe Düsseldorf)](https://globetechcdn.com/mobile_hospimedica/images/stories/articles/article_images/2024-05-30/MEDICA23_STARTUP_PARK.jpg)