Overconfidence Leads to Less Medical Diagnostic Accuracy
|
By HospiMedica International staff writers Posted on 24 Mar 2015 |
A new study reveals that while female medical students answer medical questions correctly more often than their male counterparts, they express less confidence in their answers.
To examine the association between confidence and accuracy among medical students at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine (Baltimore, MD, USA), three students gathered data from a mobile web platform they developed called Osmosis, which consists of user-generated question banks from 14,000 participants. After answering a question, a user selects one of three confidence ratings: “I'm sure,” “Feeling lucky,” or “No clue.” The researchers analyzed the responses of 1,021 users (617 men and 404 women) who answered at least 50 questions. Gender was determined based on name, and ambiguous names were omitted.
The results showed that women's answers were accurate 61.4% of the time, compared with 60.3% of the men's answers. On the other hand, women selected “I'm sure” significantly less often than men did (39.5% versus 44.4% of responses, respectively). The women also averaged a higher accuracy in responses rated both “I'm sure” and “Feeling lucky” (80.5% versus 78.3%, and 53.5% versus 49.8%, respectively). The study was published as a letter on March 3, 2105, in Annals of Internal Medicine.
“The findings are a reminder that less confidence might not indicate a lack of knowledge, and that confidence should not be mistaken for correctness,” concluded lead author Jason Theobald, BA, an MD/MBA student at New York University School of Medicine (New York, USA), and colleagues. “The decision to split groups by gender ... followed after reading several papers that found similar gender differences with respect to confidence in different settings such as mock clinical scenarios.”
“There will always be a balance in medicine between running additional diagnostic tests and being reasonably confident about the diagnosis and plan given the (possibly limited) data at hand in a clinical setting,” said study coauthor MD candidate Ryan Haynes, PhD. “As a physician, if you lean too far in either direction you're either incurring additional costs and additional stress for the patient, or you're missing potentially important diagnostic criteria.”
Related Links:
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
New York University School of Medicine
To examine the association between confidence and accuracy among medical students at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine (Baltimore, MD, USA), three students gathered data from a mobile web platform they developed called Osmosis, which consists of user-generated question banks from 14,000 participants. After answering a question, a user selects one of three confidence ratings: “I'm sure,” “Feeling lucky,” or “No clue.” The researchers analyzed the responses of 1,021 users (617 men and 404 women) who answered at least 50 questions. Gender was determined based on name, and ambiguous names were omitted.
The results showed that women's answers were accurate 61.4% of the time, compared with 60.3% of the men's answers. On the other hand, women selected “I'm sure” significantly less often than men did (39.5% versus 44.4% of responses, respectively). The women also averaged a higher accuracy in responses rated both “I'm sure” and “Feeling lucky” (80.5% versus 78.3%, and 53.5% versus 49.8%, respectively). The study was published as a letter on March 3, 2105, in Annals of Internal Medicine.
“The findings are a reminder that less confidence might not indicate a lack of knowledge, and that confidence should not be mistaken for correctness,” concluded lead author Jason Theobald, BA, an MD/MBA student at New York University School of Medicine (New York, USA), and colleagues. “The decision to split groups by gender ... followed after reading several papers that found similar gender differences with respect to confidence in different settings such as mock clinical scenarios.”
“There will always be a balance in medicine between running additional diagnostic tests and being reasonably confident about the diagnosis and plan given the (possibly limited) data at hand in a clinical setting,” said study coauthor MD candidate Ryan Haynes, PhD. “As a physician, if you lean too far in either direction you're either incurring additional costs and additional stress for the patient, or you're missing potentially important diagnostic criteria.”
Related Links:
Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
New York University School of Medicine
Latest Critical Care News
- Wearable Patch Enables Continuous Troponin Monitoring for Postoperative Cardiac Injury
- Wearable Heart Mapping May Help Identify Cardiovascular Hospitalization Risk
- Drone Network Could Speed AED Delivery for Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest
- AI Models Improve Mortality Risk Prediction After PCI for STEMI
- AI-Derived Heart Age Linked to Cardiovascular and Dementia-Related Mortality
- Updated Head Injury Guidelines Support Risk-Based CT and Observation Decisions
- Inhaled Therapy Uses Modified Bacteria to Break Down Pseudomonas Biofilms
- Miniature Wearable Sensor Enables Continuous Cuffless Blood Pressure Monitoring
- Studies Support AI-ECG for Detecting Suspected Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy
- Updated Staging System Standardizes Cardiogenic Shock Assessment
- Moldable Sensor Could Support Neck Muscle Monitoring and Rehabilitation
- Routine Opt-Out Screening Helps Increase Detection of Adolescent STIs
- Personalized fMRI-Guided TMS May Improve Severe OCD Symptoms
- Ultrasound Implant Could Help Monitor Spinal Cord Recovery After Surgery
- Paper-Based Patch Integrates Sweat Sensors and Drug-Delivery Microneedles
- Circuit-Free Smart Patch Uses Smartphone Camera to Monitor Pulse and Vessel Stiffness
Channels
Artificial Intelligence
view channel
Explainable AI Examines Sepsis Mortality Risk and Emergency Care Delays
Preventing sepsis-related deaths in emergency departments (EDs) remains challenging because patient deterioration can result from multiple rapidly evolving and interconnected factors. These include triage... Read more
Causal AI Tool Withholds Ovarian Cancer Treatment Recommendations When Evidence Insufficient
Ovarian cancer treatment often requires individualized decisions, particularly when available patient data do not clearly favor one therapeutic approach. However, artificial intelligence (AI) systems may... Read moreSurgical Techniques
view channel
Modular Robotic Surgery System Cleared for General Surgery Procedures
Upper and lower abdominal procedures, including cholecystectomy, hernia repair, small-bowel resection, and gastric bypass, account for approximately 3.5 million operations annually in the U.... Read more
FDA Authorizes Robotic System for En Bloc Bladder Resection
Bladder cancer frequently recurs, making accurate staging essential for treatment planning. Conventional transurethral resection can fragment tumors, complicating margin assessment and detrusor muscle... Read more
Fluorescence Imaging Reveals Nerves Under Normal Operating-Room Lighting
Preventing unintended nerve injury remains a major concern during surgery, particularly in complex anatomical regions where nerves can be difficult to distinguish from surrounding tissue.... Read more
Programmable Microwave Ablation System Gains CE Mark for Minimally Invasive Tissue Ablation
Hospitals continue to seek minimally invasive approaches that simplify procedural planning and provide controlled energy delivery for tissue ablation. Thermal ablation systems are used across multiple... Read morePatient Care
view channelVirtual Reality Program May Reduce Anxiety Before Pediatric Surgery
Presurgery anxiety affects an estimated 50% to 75% of children undergoing surgery and can complicate anesthesia induction, increase postoperative pain, and prolong recovery. Sedation is often used to manage... Read more
Video-Based Support Helps Older Adults Clarify Kidney Disease Treatment Preferences
Advanced chronic kidney disease (CKD) involves progressive loss of kidney function that can lead to kidney failure and difficult treatment decisions. For older adults, these decisions may include choosing... Read moreMedical Imaging
view channel
AI Uses Routine MRI to Predict Deep Brain Stimulation Response in Dystonia
Dystonia is a debilitating neurological movement disorder characterized by involuntary muscle contractions that cause abnormal movements and postures. Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is one of the few treatments... Read more
AI Combines Brain Imaging Features to Identify Cognitive Impairment in CKD
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) can affect multiple organs, including the brain, with cognitive impairment emerging as a common complication. Changes in executive function, attention, and memory can reduce... Read moreAI Software Gains FDA Clearance for Brain Aneurysm Detection and Follow-Up
Unruptured intracranial aneurysms are often asymptomatic and can be difficult to detect on head computed tomography angiography, especially in busy acute-care workflows. Missed or delayed identification... Read more
Lung Ultrasound Predicts Progression of Interstitial Lung Abnormalities in Rheumatoid Arthritis
Interstitial lung abnormalities are a pulmonary concern in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, requiring monitoring to detect disease progression. However, tracking these changes often involves repeated... Read moreHealth IT
view channel
Telemonitoring Program Improves Quality of Life After Heart Failure Discharge
Heart failure is a chronic condition associated with high mortality, frequent hospitalizations, and reduced quality of life. Patients face particularly high risks of readmission and death after discharge,... Read more
Clinical Decision Support Tool Automates CKD Risk Assessment in Primary Care
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) requires timely diagnosis, risk assessment, and coordinated treatment in primary care. Delayed recognition can affect decisions about testing, blood pressure control, cardiovascular... Read morePoint of Care
view channel
Handheld Imaging Device May Help Identify Preterm Birth Risk Earlier
Preterm birth, defined as delivery before 37 weeks of pregnancy, can lead to serious neonatal complications, including neurological, developmental, and respiratory problems. However, identifying pregnancies... Read more
New Breath Condensate Testing Approach Enhances Reliability for COPD Monitoring
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a progressive lung condition that can increasingly impair breathing over time. Diagnosis and monitoring may be burdensome because patients often require... Read more
Continuous Glucose Monitoring Identifies Cardiometabolic Risk in Adults Without Diabetes
Dysglycemia—abnormal blood glucose regulation—can fluctuate throughout the day and often escape conventional screening. Clinicians typically rely on fasting plasma glucose and hemoglobin A1c, which offer... Read moreBusiness
view channel
Stryker Completes Acquisition to Broaden Shoulder Surgery Offerings
Stryker (Portage, MI, USA) has completed its acquisition of ZuriMED (Zurich, Switzerland), a privately held developer of the FiberLocker System, expanding its Sports Medicine portfolio with a commercialized... Read more







