Lack of Autonomy and Respect Devalue Doctors’ Standing
By HospiMedica International staff writers Posted on 25 Apr 2016 |
A new study reveals that while physicians in the United States feel that their profession is in conflict with changing healthcare dynamics, 32% of young Americans think they could be doctors with little or no training.
The “Truth About Doctors” study involved interviews with 450 doctors across the US, in addition to an update of consumer survey information gleaned from the McCann “Truth About Wellness” study. The study, jointly conducted by McCann Health (New York, NY, USA) and McCann Truth Central (New York, NY, USA), found that the pressures of today's world have not only stolen time and autonomy from doctors, but have simultaneously demanded they do more on someone else's agenda.
Demographically, 30% of the doctors surveyed were actively employed in primary care, and 70% were specialists; 45% of the respondents were female and 55% male. A majority (51%) of the doctors selected frustration as the dominant emotion governing their professional life, followed by anxiety (39%). One of the major frustrations cited were patients who diagnose themselves on websites such as WebMD, which according to the doctors, result in 74% of them misdiagnosing themselves; 57% also said that patients do not take the doctor’s advice because they think they know better.
“Modern-day doctors have become trapped in a paradoxical standard where they're expected to forge a warm relationship with patients, yet operate with the cold precision of a machine,” said study coauthor Laura Simpson, executive VP and global director of McCann Truth Central. “In our real-time, know-it-all culture, their authority and respect are eroding right under their feet. Advancing technology and the evolving healthcare system will redefine ‘doctorness’ in the next decade.”
“While patient empowerment and transparency in healthcare are good things, they can sometimes be at odds,” said Amar Urhekar, President of McCann Health Americas. “The insights from our ‘Truth About Doctors’ study suggest that a major paradigm shift is needed in the way healthcare stakeholders communicate with doctors in order to achieve better results. As communications experts, we must begin to create value-based messaging that supports doctors beyond the traditional brand story.”
Related Links:
McCann Health
McCann Truth Central
The “Truth About Doctors” study involved interviews with 450 doctors across the US, in addition to an update of consumer survey information gleaned from the McCann “Truth About Wellness” study. The study, jointly conducted by McCann Health (New York, NY, USA) and McCann Truth Central (New York, NY, USA), found that the pressures of today's world have not only stolen time and autonomy from doctors, but have simultaneously demanded they do more on someone else's agenda.
Demographically, 30% of the doctors surveyed were actively employed in primary care, and 70% were specialists; 45% of the respondents were female and 55% male. A majority (51%) of the doctors selected frustration as the dominant emotion governing their professional life, followed by anxiety (39%). One of the major frustrations cited were patients who diagnose themselves on websites such as WebMD, which according to the doctors, result in 74% of them misdiagnosing themselves; 57% also said that patients do not take the doctor’s advice because they think they know better.
“Modern-day doctors have become trapped in a paradoxical standard where they're expected to forge a warm relationship with patients, yet operate with the cold precision of a machine,” said study coauthor Laura Simpson, executive VP and global director of McCann Truth Central. “In our real-time, know-it-all culture, their authority and respect are eroding right under their feet. Advancing technology and the evolving healthcare system will redefine ‘doctorness’ in the next decade.”
“While patient empowerment and transparency in healthcare are good things, they can sometimes be at odds,” said Amar Urhekar, President of McCann Health Americas. “The insights from our ‘Truth About Doctors’ study suggest that a major paradigm shift is needed in the way healthcare stakeholders communicate with doctors in order to achieve better results. As communications experts, we must begin to create value-based messaging that supports doctors beyond the traditional brand story.”
Related Links:
McCann Health
McCann Truth Central
Latest Hospital News News
- Nurse Tracking System Improves Hospital Workflow
- New Children’s Hospital Transforms California Healthcare
- Noisy Hospitals Face Threat of Decreased Federal Compensation
- Orthopedics Centre of Excellence Planned for Guy’s Hospital
- Research Suggests Avoidance of Low-Value Surgical Procedures
- U.S. Federal Readmission Fines Linked to Higher Mortality
- Columbia China to Build New Hospital in Jiaxing
- Dubai Debuts Second Robotic Pharmacy Service
- Seattle Hospital Network Shifts Away from Overlapping Surgeries
- ACC to Launch Valvular Heart Disease Program in China
- Mortality Rates Lower at Major Teaching Hospitals
- South Australia to Inaugurate Upscale Hospital
- Raffles to Launch Second Hospital Project in China
- Research Center Tackles Antimicrobial Drugs Challenge
- Miami Cardiac & Vascular Institute Completes Expansion Project
- Hospital Antibiotic Policies Improve Prescription Practices